One of the most common causes of tension in a rental property is repairs. When something goes wrong, the first question is usually a simple one: who pays? In reality, the answer depends on the type of repair, how the issue was caused, and what the law says.
Understanding where responsibility sits can help avoid disputes, delays and unexpected costs for both landlords and tenants.
The Legal Basics
In the UK, landlords have clear legal responsibilities when it comes to repairs. These are mainly set out in the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985 and apply regardless of what a tenancy agreement says.
Landlords are responsible for:
The structure and exterior of the property, including walls, roof, windows and doors
Heating and hot water systems
Gas, electricity, plumbing and sanitation
Fixed installations such as boilers, radiators and wiring
Tenants also have legal responsibilities. These include:
Taking reasonable care of the property
Carrying out day-to-day upkeep
Reporting issues promptly
Avoiding damage caused by misuse or neglect
The tenancy agreement can provide clarity on expectations, but it cannot remove a landlord’s legal repair obligations.
A Simple Rule of Thumb
A helpful way to think about repair responsibility is this:
Fair wear and tear is the landlord’s responsibility
Damage is usually the tenant’s responsibility
Fair wear and tear considers the age and condition of the item at the start of the tenancy, how long the tenant has lived there, and how the property has been used. Items naturally deteriorate over time, and landlords are expected to plan for this.
Repairs Usually Paid for by the Landlord
In most cases, landlords will cover the cost of repairs relating to the fabric of the building and essential services, including:
Structural problems such as roof leaks or cracked walls
Plumbing issues, including leaks and faulty pipework
Boiler breakdowns and heating system failures
Electrical faults with fixed wiring or sockets
Built-in appliances supplied with the property
Damp or mould caused by building defects or poor insulation
These are considered essential to keeping the property safe and habitable.
Repairs Usually Paid for by the Tenant
Tenants are normally responsible for issues caused by their actions or lack of care, such as:
Damage caused by misuse, accidents or neglect
Blocked sinks or toilets caused by inappropriate items
Broken fixtures due to force or impact
Lost keys or damage to locks requiring replacement
Everyday consumables such as light bulbs, batteries and fuses
If something breaks because it has been used incorrectly, the tenant may be asked to cover the cost.
Grey Areas and Common Disputes
Some situations are not always clear cut and can lead to disagreement.
Appliances are a common example. If a washing machine fails due to age or normal use, the landlord will usually pay. If it breaks because it has been overloaded or misused, the tenant may be responsible.
Mould is another frequent issue. If it is caused by structural problems or poor ventilation, it is generally a landlord issue. If it is the result of lifestyle factors, such as not ventilating the property properly, responsibility may sit with the tenant.
Other grey areas include garden maintenance, carpets and flooring, and the breakdown of white goods. In these cases, evidence and communication are key.
What Happens in an Emergency?
Emergency repairs are those that pose a risk to health, safety or the property itself. This might include a burst pipe, total loss of heating in winter, or a serious electrical fault.
Tenants should always report emergencies immediately using the agreed contact method. In limited circumstances, tenants may arrange urgent repairs themselves if they cannot reach the landlord or agent, but this should be a last resort and costs should be reasonable and evidenced.
The Importance of Inventories
A detailed inventory and check-in report can prevent many repair disputes. These documents record the condition of the property and its contents at the start of the tenancy.
Photos, descriptions and condition notes make it much easier to determine whether an issue is due to wear and tear or damage. They protect both landlords and tenants and are invaluable if disagreements arise.
How Letting Agents Can Help
A good letting agent acts as a neutral middle ground. They can:
Assess repair issues fairly
Arrange reliable contractors
Manage approvals and costs
Keep communication clear and documented
This often leads to faster resolutions and fewer disputes.
Tips to Avoid Repair Disagreements
Clear expectations from the beginning make a big difference. This includes:
A well-written tenancy agreement
Explaining responsibilities at move-in
Encouraging prompt reporting of problems
Carrying out regular property inspections
Small issues dealt with early are usually cheaper and easier to fix.
Final Thoughts
Repair responsibilities do not have to be a source of conflict. When both landlords and tenants understand who pays for what, issues are resolved more quickly and relationships are smoother.
If you are ever unsure about responsibility for a specific repair, getting advice early can save time, money and stress for everyone involved.
Maddie Lancaster is an ARLA qualified letting agent with over 10 years of experience in the UK rental market. Rent East Yorkshire specialises in property management services for landlords across the East Riding of Yorkshire.
Disclaimer: This information is provided for guidance only and does not constitute legal advice. Specific legal advice should be sought for particular circumstances.
Share this post: